Coffee Club Comparison: Bean Box Vs. Mistobox

By

Bryan Huynh

on March 02, 2025

header image

Key Takeaways

  • Coffee clubs are subscription services that deliver coffee directly to your home or office on a regular basis, with options for different delivery frequencies. Two popular coffee clubs mentioned in the article are Bean Box and Mistobox.
  • Bean Box offers a variety of coffee choices, including different tasting experiences, ground options, and delivery frequencies. They emphasize freshness and offer free shipping with a satisfaction guarantee.
  • Mistobox also provides a range of coffee options, allowing you to customize your subscription based on your taste preferences. They offer a wide selection of coffees from around the world but have a $5 shipping fee.
  • Choosing between Bean Box and Mistobox ultimately depends on personal preferences, including taste, shipping fees, and the desire to try a variety of coffees.

Many people can't get their day started without drinking at least one cup of coffee, while others must drink multiple cups before they are even remotely functional. If you're a regular coffee drinker, you probably don't like running out of your favorite choices. Grocery stores can sometimes offer limited choices, which is why many habitable coffee drinkers opt to subscribe to coffee clubs.

A coffee club is a subscription service, similar to a magazine subscription, that enables you to choose your preferred coffee choices and have them shipped directly to your home or office regularly. This could be weekly, monthly, bi-weekly, etc. If you were to conduct an internet search for coffee clubs, you would discover that there are many choices available. If there are so many choices available, how does one go about choosing the perfect club?

Choosing the perfect coffee club doesn't have to be an overwhelming task. To choose the coffee subscription that will best meet your needs, you will first need to find out what's available and which clubs offer what. Out of the many coffee subscriptions available, two particularly popular choices are Bean Box and Mistobox. Here are extensive overviews of both Mistobox and Bean Box, so you can decide which coffee subscription might work best for you.

All About Bean Box Coffee Subscription

Bean Box was created in Seattle on the idea that coffee is more of an experience than a beverage, and this is what many of their regular subscribers believe, too. Bean Box began in 2014 when they shipped off their first box of coffee to their very first customer. That was a momentous moment, and since then, Bean Box has grown exponentially. Today, ten years later, Bean Box owners have numerous subscribers who look forward to receiving their coffee regularly.

What to Expect From Bean Box's Subscriptions?

It only takes minutes to sign up for a Bean Box subscription, and you'll quickly be on your way to receiving your first box of coffee, which you are likely to immensely enjoy. To start a subscription, you will need to do the following:

  1. Choose Your Ground
  2. Choose Your Ideal Tasting Experience
  3. Choose the Amount of Coffee Included in Each Delivery
  4. Choose the Frequency at Which You'll Receive Your Coffee

What's the Good, the Bad, and the Great About Bean Box?

Bean Box is a wonderful coffee subscription service that has both positive and negative aspects. Bean Box offers delicious, high-quality coffee from suppliers from around the world. Their gourmet coffee has become very popular over the past ten years because Bean Box owners are willing to go above and beyond to provide a wonderful experience for all their customers.

What's Good about Bean Box?

Many things are good about Bean Box coffee subscriptions. The fact that you get free shipping on every order is definitely a good thing that many members love. Shipping costs can quickly add up, and most customers appreciate not having to pay to receive their favorite coffees. Another good thing about Bean Box is, that if you're ever dissatisfied with a particular coffee, you don't have to worry about getting stuck with it. As long as you return the coffee within 15 calendar days, you will receive a full refund!

What's Bad about Bean Box?

There aren't many bad things that can be said about Bean Box because they're absolutely wonderful. However, some customers have complained about a few things: the inability to choose their grind setting when choosing the "ground" selection, and the higher cost of Bean Box's coffee subscriptions in comparison to other coffee clubs. To most people, these aren't bad enough to keep them from enjoying their favorite Bean Box coffee, and they're still able to fully enjoy their memberships.

What's Great About Bean Box?

Bean Box certainly has many reasons to brag, and one major reason why Bean Box should be proud is that each bag of coffee is freshly ground within 48 hours before being shipped to you. Another thing that is great about Bean Box is that it's always easy to switch to a different roast at any time, whether you initially opted for espresso, and you've decided to try the light roast, or something completely different.

Cost of a Bean Box Subscription

Again, if you opt to receive coffee very frequently, your cost per bag will be less. There is a promotion that you can take advantage of, which enables you to receive 50% off on your first order. After that, you'll pay as little as $17.78 to as much as $20.76 per shipment.

How Are Bean Box Coffees Packaged?

Bean Box coffees are packaged in food-grade bags that are vacuum sealed and consist of one-way valves that ensure the freshness of the coffee beans. Bean Box's bags are also puncture-proof and prevent contaminants from compromising the coffee.

Who is Mistobox?

Mistobox is another great contender in the coffee subscription business, and they were first introduced in 2012. Since then, Mistobox's sales have exploded, which has exceeded their expectations. They're proud of their simple mission, which is to make it easy for you to discover and brew the world's best coffee at home. Like Bean Box, it's quick and easy to sign up for a Mistobox subscription. To sign up, simply visit their website and do the following:

  1. Choose How You Take Your Coffee
  2. Choose Your Grind -
  3. Choose Your Favorite Roast Level
  4. Choose Your Preferred Coffee Type
  5. Choose Your Delivery Frequency
  6. Choose Your Tier
  7. Choose Your Coffee Plan

The Good, the Bad, and the Great About Mistobox

Mistobox makes it easy to start a subscription and start receiving some of the best and the most unique coffee you've ever tasted. While shopping for a subscription, you can also purchase gift subscriptions for friends and family, and you can even purchase any equipment necessary to make the perfect cup of coffee.

What's Good About Mistobox?

There are many good things about Mistobox. Not only does Mistobox send out coffee subscription packages using attractive and eye-catching boxes, but Mistobox's prices are affordable.

What's Bad About Mistobox?

Mistobox is loved by many people around the world, and they have numerous subscribers. Unfortunately, people dislike the fact that there is a $5 shipping cost for each order. Another thing about the Mistobox coffee subscription service that people aren't too happy about is the fact that their bags of coffee only come in one size, and there are no sampler packs available. There's no guarantee that you'll like all the coffee that's sent to you, and many subscribers dislike being stuck with coffee they don't like.

What's Great About MistoBox?

Mistobox offers a staggering 600+ coffees from growers around the world. For coffee lovers, this can be exciting, as this allows subscribers to enjoy a substantial amount of new coffee regularly.

Cost of a Mistobox Subscription

With Mistobox, you will pay as little as $12.71 per bag, with a $5 shipping fee. If you purchase the 12 coffee subscription, your costs will be the lowest per bag.

What is Mistobox's Packaging Like?

In 2022, Mistobox was very pleased to announce to subscribers that they switched their coffee packaging to 100% compostable and biodegradable materials. So, Mistobox customers can toss empty bags of coffee in their gardens, which will add benefit to the soil.

Is Bean Box or Mistobox Better?

Determining whether Bean Box or Mistobox is better is a matter of opinion. To provide an accurate answer, it would be necessary to try out a subscription from one or even both companies, to see what you think. Only then will you truly know which one you prefer more? However, everyone is different, which is why answering this question without knowing all aspects of each coffee subscription wouldn't be valid.

If the idea of trying out a huge number of different coffees from around the world, then Mistobox wins and should likely be your choice. Not many coffee clubs offer access to such a massive number of coffees from growers from around the world.

If you like receiving your coffee without being charged a shipping fee, Bean Box should be your choice. Mistobox charges a $5 shipping cost whether you purchase one bag or multiple bags, and those $5 fees tend to add up over time.

If you need to base your decision on flavor, again, subscribing to Bean Box first, and then Mistobox, might be necessary. You'll need to actually taste the coffee that is sent to determine which coffee club sends the best coffee. If you're not picky about your coffee, and you just want to ensure that you never run out, then either coffee club would suffice. You must make a decision based on other factors.

Some coffee lovers decide between Bean Box and Mistobox based on how their name sounds, or how the packaging looks. However, you might have a different way of deciding. All in all, Bean Box and Mistobox are both wonderful and extremely popular coffee clubs, and you can't go wrong regardless of which one you ultimately choose.

It's obvious that both Bean Box and Mistobox have several positive aspects that far outweigh the negative. If you've narrowed down your choices to these two choices and you're struggling to decide, you have some options. Since these two contenders both have a lot to offer, you might want to toss a coin to make an immediate choice.

If you're not into tossing coins, you could decide which coffee club is better based on their reviews, the different types of coffees they have to offer, the cost of shipping, and more. It might take a while to decide whether analyzing all of these factors can take time. However, once you've made a final choice, chances are you'll be very satisfied with your coffee. Of course, if you aren't happy with your final choice, you can always make changes until your expectations are met.

About the Author

Product Tester & Writer

Bryan Huynh

Product Tester & Writer

Bryan Huynh is a determined Product Tester & Writer. Being a coffee addict, it is only right that he mainly tests and reviews different coffee from around the world and coffee subscription services.

Bryan Huynh is a determined Product Tester & Writer. Being a coffee addict, it is only right that he mainly tests and reviews different coffee from around the world and coffee subscription services.